domingo, 26 de enero de 2020

BioEdge: Can a foetus feel pain as early as 12 weeks?

BioEdge: Can a foetus feel pain as early as 12 weeks?
Bioedge
Can a foetus feel pain as early as 12 weeks?
    
The debate over abortion is not just about women’s reproductive rights. It is also about science. And none of these debates is more heated than foetal pain. Many contend that the upper time limit for abortion should be 20 weeks, as from then on, it can feel pain.
Mother Jones – not a scientific journal, mind you, but a benchmark for conventional thinking on the pro-choice side of the debate – says that this claim is “bunk”, or more politely, “scientifically dubious”. The Guttmacher Institute concurs. It says that the position of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists is that the foetus cannot feel pain until the third trimester, well beyond 20 weeks and viability. It also cites a 2005 review of research which reached the same conclusion. The foetus may recoil from stimuli, but this does not mean it feels pain. Furthermore, pain is “subjective”, and the foetus is not developed enough to understand pain.
However, an article in the Journal of Medical Ethics – which is by no means a pro-life publication – suggests that the conventional thinking should be rethought.
Stuart WG Derbyshire, a psychologist at the National University of Singapore, and John C. Bockmann, a physician assistant at Conner Troop Medical Clinic, in New York, are on opposite sides of the debate about the morality of abortion. But they write that “moral views on abortion should not interfere with discussion of whether fetal pain is possible and whether the science of fetal development can rule out the possibility of fetal pain.”
They believe that the research shows that a foetus can feel pain as early as 12 weeks.
First of all, they argue, “all clinicians or surgeons working with fetal patients advocate the use of fetal anaesthesia and analgesia as standard practice.” Abortion is the single exception, because doctors are focused on the welfare of the mother, not the of the foetus.
Second, “there never was a consensus that fetal pain is not possible before 24 weeks”. This limit was based on the notion that the cortex is needed to experience pain, but recent research suggests that pain is not coupled to the cortex.
Third, the definition of pain is fraught. A common understanding of pain requires that a human be able to reflect upon his sensations. This restricts genuine pain to fairly mature humans and excludes most animals. The authors “propose that the fetus experiences a pain that just is and it is because it is, there is no further comprehension of the experience, only an immediate apprehension. The fetus experiences something that is inherent to a certain level of biological activity, and which emerges at an unknown time often speculated to be after 12 weeks’ gestation.”
So, they conclude, “Given the evidence that the fetus might be able to experience something like pain during later abortions, it seems reasonable that the clinical team and the pregnant woman are encouraged to consider fetal analgesia.”
Michael Cook is editor of BioEdge
Bioedge
Belgium's historic trial of three doctors for illegally killing a mentally ill woman in 2010 gives a glimpse of what's going on backstage in its euthanasia system. Whether or not they are convicted -- and on past form, this is unlikely -- I don't think that anyone will be able to claim that it works with clockwork efficiency and compassion. It's a sad and shabby business.
 
m.png
Michael Cook
Editor
BioEdge
 Comment on BioedgeFind Us on FacebookFollow us on Twitter
NEWS THIS WEEK
by Michael Cook | Jan 26, 2020
Sadder and more complicated
 
 
by Michael Cook | Jan 26, 2020
Addresses huge crowd at Washington DC rally
 
 
by Michael Cook | Jan 26, 2020
Surrogacy could be more dangerous that people think
 
 
by Michael Cook | Jan 26, 2020
We need to revisit the issue, say ethicists
 
 
by Michael Cook | Jan 26, 2020
Experts believe that only a few will take advantage of it
 
 
by Michael Cook | Jan 26, 2020
Evolution has designed us for shorter relationships
 
 
by Michael Cook | Jan 26, 2020
Exciting new uses
 
 
by Xavier Symons | Jan 26, 2020
A new JME article makes the case for harvesting sperm from dead donors.   
Bioedge
BioEdge
Level 1, 488 Botany Road, Alexandria NSW 2015 Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
Mobile: 0422-691-615

No hay comentarios:

Publicar un comentario