A universal basic income won’t do everyone good
“Wealth without work” is one of seven blunders that lead to violence, Gandhi was supposed to have said according to a Facebook post. This addresses the core of why a “universal basic income” (UBI) won’t do everyone good.
UBI, the direct payment by government of money to all citizens, to top up or instead of wages, is an old idea that dates back to the Enlightenment. In recent times, it has enjoyed resurgent popularity and support, even among political groups supposedly at opposite ends of the spectrum, such as libertarians and socialists. Early this June, for instance, Switzerland held a referendum on a constitutional amendment that would pave the way for it. The proposal was finally rejected. However, in 2017, Finland aims to put one such policy into effect, providing citizens with up to €800 a month. Some cities in Holland are considering doing something similar, albeit in a more limited scale.
The majority of opponents, on the other hand, would prefer a “wait and see” attitude on the real effects of technological change on labor. Indeed, lots of people lost their jobs when horse-drawn carriages became obsolete, but there were many more who found new and higher paying ones in the automobile industry. Perhaps UBI is too drastic a cure for a temporary problem that will sort itself out in due course. Others insist that these direct and unconditional government transfers are just too costly for their intended effect and unsustainable in the long term.
What hardly anyone refers to is the intrinsic value of work for human dignity and wellbeing. Discussions have mostly focused on work as a source of income and ignored other perhaps even more important benefits. Not only does work prevent us from engaging in harmful, antisocial activities, but it also furnishes our lives with meaning and a sense of identity, as well as order and structure to our families and societies. This is not something that UBI can supply, even if economists figured out a way to afford it. Work is the universal, time-tested method through which human beings learn, acquire skills and develop all sorts of distinctive excellences or virtues. That is something no government dole-out can replace.
The author teaches Business Ethics at the University of Navarre. His latest book is “Happiness and Virtue Ethics in Business. The Ultimate Value Proposition”.
Will there be enough work? That’s the basic question facing developed economies with flat growth as employment shifts from agriculture and manufacturing to services. It appears that there might not be jobs for the uneducated and unskilled.
|A universal basic income won’t do everyone good|
Alejo Jose G. Sison | FEATURES | 20 June 2016
What if there isn’t enough work to go around?
|A fanfare of failures|
Juliette Peers | POPCORN | 20 June 2016
Why have so many recent films celebrated artistic and sporting failures?
|Murder and intrigue at the seaside|
Carolyn Moynihan | FEATURES | 20 June 2016
MercatorNet readers reveal their favourite crime reads for the beach.
|A picture perfect book for vacation reading|
Jennifer Minicus | READING MATTERS | 20 June 2016
A picture book worth the investment
|The Canada Family Life Project finds immediate action needed|
Shannon Roberts | DEMOGRAPHY IS DESTINY | 20 June 2016
What Canadians say about elder care.
Suite 12A, Level 2, 5 George Street, North Strathfied NSW 2137, Australia
Designed by elleston
New Media Foundation | Suite 12A, Level 2, 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | AUSTRALIA | +61 2 8005 8605
MercatorNet: A universal basic income won’t do everyone good